Air travel often sparks debates about shared spaces, and overhead bins are a prime example. A recent viral TikTok video highlighted passenger frustration with a neighbor's photo-taking habits near the window, illustrating the close quarters of air travel. But another common in-flight quarrel revolves around carry-on luggage and overhead bin usage. Discussions are rife on social media platforms like Reddit, with passengers sharing their experiences and opinions on where to store carry-ons and the often-unclear policies surrounding them.
One traveler's Reddit post in the "r/unitedairlines" forum sparked a conversation about overhead bin “ownership.” The poster recounted a flight where the flight attendant announced that carry-ons didn't need to be stowed directly above passengers' seats and encouraged utilizing any available overhead space. Given the full flight, passengers scrambled to find room, and those with smaller bags were asked to place them under the seat in front of them. This seemingly reasonable request ignited a debate about carry-on sizes, with some Redditors pointing out the prevalence of oversized “monster” carry-ons and the practice of bringing multiple bags onboard.
The issue of passengers exceeding their carry-on allowances and bringing oversized personal items also surfaced. Some users expressed frustration with passengers boarding with multiple bags, including carry-ons, backpacks, computer bags, and purses, leaving little room for others. The timing of boarding also played a role in the discussion, with some noting that early boarders often fill the overhead bins, leaving later groups with limited options and potentially forcing gate-checking.
Even the placement of smaller personal items within the overhead bin became a point of contention. One Reddit user in the "r/onebag" forum questioned the etiquette of placing a backpack in the overhead bin, even if it could fit under the seat, to maximize legroom. This sparked further debate, with some arguing that purchased tickets include overhead bin space, while others emphasized the importance of prioritizing larger carry-ons.
Etiquette expert Rosalinda Randall weighed in on the matter, emphasizing that overhead bins are intended for carry-on luggage, not smaller personal items. She advised passengers to place their carry-ons in the bins above their assigned row whenever possible. If those bins are full, she suggested placing the bag a few rows behind and, if necessary, politely requesting gate-checking. Randall also stressed the importance of waiting to retrieve carry-ons until it can be done without inconveniencing others. She highlighted several inconsiderate carry-on behaviors, such as placing bags in a higher class of service, taking someone else's spot, or carelessly handling other passengers' belongings when stowing luggage.
Ultimately, the overhead bin debate underscores the need for clear communication from airlines and consideration from passengers to ensure a smoother travel experience for everyone.
